Introduction
Electrical motors are a big part of many industrial and commercial applications. However, like all mechanical devices, they are prone to failures. In this post, we will dive into the most common issues faced by two popular types of motors: induction motors and permanent magnet (PM) motors with inner and outer rotors. Understanding these problems is the first step in preventing costly downtime and improving the lifespan of your machines.
1. Bearing Failures
• Cause: Bearings are critical in both induction and PM motors, as they are supporting rotating components. Bearings failures can be divided into two categories, mechanical failure and lubrication failure. Mechanical failures are usually caused by wrong sizing of the bearings and misalignment. The Lubrication failures, on the other hand are caused by too high or too low temperatures, too high speed and contamination.
• Symptoms: Noise, excessive vibration, and overheating.
• Prevention: Correct sizing, regular inspection, maintaining proper alignment, and keeping contaminants out of the system.
2. Stator Winding Failures
• Induction Motors:
• Cause: The winding failures are usually caused by mechanical damages during production, electrical overload, aging and moisture.
The electrical overload failures are caused by high voltage spikes with short rise times, which results in sparks inside the motor, this is also the case for inverter duty motors, which is why they’ll need additional insulation.
The aging failures are usually caused by too high temperatures, usually a class f insulation system operated at 155 degrees Celsius, will have a life time of 10.000 hours. and if the operating temperature of the winding is reduced by 10 degrees, to 145 degrees Celcius, then the life time will double, which results in 20.000 hrs. on the other hand if the temperature is increased by 10 degrees, then the life time will be half, 5.000 hours.
The moisture failures are caused by the winding insulation material absorbing the moisture and thereby reducing the insulation resistance.
• Symptoms: Reduced efficiency, excessive current draw, or the motor not starting at all.
• Prevention: Ensure proper cooling, avoid voltage spikes, for opperation in humid environments, use topicalized windings and at last check that insulation system is tested prior to commissioning.
3. Rotor Bar Failures (Induction Motors)
• Cause: Rotor bars in induction motors can crack or break due to mechanical stress or thermal cycling.
• Symptoms: Excessive vibration, torque reduction, or loss of motor speed.
• Prevention: Routine monitoring using motor current analysis (MCA) and avoiding excessive load cycling.
4. Demagnetization in PM Motors
• Cause: PM motors are vulnerable to demagnetization, especially in outer rotor configurations. Factors include high temperatures, overloading, and excessive current.
• Symptoms: Decreased torque, lower motor speed, or complete motor failure.
• Prevention: Thermal management and avoiding conditions that may generate excessive heat or current surges.
5. Shaft Misalignment and Coupling Issues
• Cause: Misalignment between the motor and the load it drives is a frequent cause of failure in both induction and PM motors.
• Symptoms: Vibration, increased bearing wear, and coupling failures.
• Prevention: Regular alignment checks and using flexible couplings when possible.
6. Thermal Overload
• Induction Motors:
• Cause: Excessive current can lead to overheating of the windings, causing insulation breakdown.
• Symptoms: Motor tripping, lower efficiency, or complete breakdown.
• Prevention: Choosing the right insulation system class, Installing thermal sensors and maintaining proper cooling.
• PM Motors:
• Cause: PM motors, particularly outer rotor designs, are more vulnerable to thermal overload due to less effective heat dissipation.
• Symptoms: Demagnetization, loss of torque, or motor failure.
• Prevention: Enhanced cooling systems and better thermal insulation for the magnets.
7. Electrical Faults: Grounding and Short Circuits
• Induction Motors:
• Cause: Electrical faults can occur from insulation breakdown or moisture penetration, leading to ground faults or short circuits.
• Symptoms: Circuit breakers tripping, loss of motor function.
• Prevention: Regular insulation tests, moisture control, and ensuring a solid grounding system.
• PM Motors:
• Cause: Similar electrical faults can occur in PM motors, especially in high-power applications.
• Symptoms: Unusual noise, overheating, or immediate failure.
• Prevention: Proper system insulation and maintaining a clean, dry operational environment.
Conclusion
No motor is immune to failure, but many common issues can be avoided with by choosing the right motor for the application, regular maintenance, proper installation, and monitoring. By staying vigilant about these typical failures, you can extend the life of your induction and PM motors, improve reliability, and reduce unexpected downtime.
References
1. EASA (Electrical Apparatus Service Association). Root Cause Failure Analysis. EASA’s guidelines on identifying and addressing common motor failures, with specific sections on bearing failure, stator winding issues, and rotor bar problems in induction motors.
Available at: https://easa.com/resources/troubleshooting/root-cause-failure-analysis
3. ABB Motors and Generators. Bearing Failures and Their Prevention in Electric Motors. ABB’s comprehensive guide on common bearing issues, lubrication practices, and best alignment practices to prevent premature wear.
Available at: https://new.abb.com/motors-generators
4. SKF Bearings. Bearing Damage and Failure Analysis. SKF’s manual explains various types of bearing failures and prevention strategies, crucial for both induction and PM motors.
Available at: https://www.skf.com/group/products/bearings-units-housings/bearing-failure
6. Nidec Corporation. Common Electrical Faults in Motors and How to Prevent Them. This whitepaper details electrical faults like grounding issues, short circuits, and thermal overload across motor types, including induction and PM motors.
Available at: https://www.nidec.com/en/technology/electrical-faults
At last, thank you for reading and don’t forget to sign up to our newsletter to recieve links to our newest posts about PMSMs and other electro magnetic topics. Don’t worry we will not send more than 1 mail per month.